
近期受邀在大学毕业典礼上发表演讲的科技行业领袖,或许已经意识到向年轻人大肆宣扬人工智能并不受欢迎,因此调整了演讲内容。但事实证明,今年毕业季,重磅演讲嘉宾与毕业生之间的矛盾,远不止人工智能一项。
谷歌和Alphabet首席执行官桑达尔·皮查伊是今年最新一位遭冷遇的科技高管。上周日,当拥有斯坦福大学硕士学位的皮查伊登台演讲时,该校2026届毕业生集体离场。
此次离场行动由Students for Justice in Palestine斯坦福分会发起,该组织是由全美各地学生自主运营、主张巴勒斯坦解放的活动团体。该分会在Instagram发表声明,指控谷歌涉嫌与以色列政府、人工智能和数据分析公司Palantir等企业开展合作;Palantir已签订多项合约,为以色列军方、特朗普政府移民执法项目提供技术支持。
长期以来,活动人士一直批评谷歌的“Project Nimbus”——这是以色列2021年与谷歌、亚马逊签署的价值12亿美元的合同,据此,以色列军方可使用先进的云计算和人工智能软件。近年来多个亲巴勒斯坦团体接连发起抗议,谷歌管理层甚至遭到公司内部员工抗议。
记者向谷歌寻求置评,谷歌发言人援引了皮查伊演讲中的相关表述。斯坦福大学并未立即回应《财富》杂志的置评请求。
该活动团体在声明中称,数百名学生参与了抗议活动,而SFGate上周日报道称,约有200名毕业生离场。
“今天,数百名学生以实际行动向桑达尔·皮查伊表明,高薪福利或人工智能飞速发展的说辞,再也无法蛊惑他们。”该组织在声明中写道。
反AI情绪席卷全美高校
过去一个月,全美各地的毕业典礼演讲嘉宾都遭遇全场嘘声,学生普遍对“人工智能即将彻底重塑职场”的论调存疑。
上月,中佛罗里达大学毕业典礼上,房地产高管格洛丽亚·考尔菲尔德(Gloria Caulfield)称人工智能是“下一场工业革命”,话音刚落便引发全场嘘声。数日后,在亚利桑那大学的演讲现场,皮查伊的前任之一、谷歌前CEO埃里克·施密特(Eric Schmidt)按照预先准备好的发言稿阐述人工智能融入年轻人生活是必然趋势时,台下嘘声一片,他不得不暂停发言。
皮查伊早已预判到针对人工智能的抗议,整场演讲完全避开相关字眼。
“我知道今天本该给各位分享建议。但最近不少人叮嘱我该讲什么、不该讲什么,所有人给我的忠告都指向同一个需要避开的话题。”他说道。
皮查伊虽未提及人工智能,但表示这项技术“与本次演讲无关”。他在演讲中鼓励毕业生保持乐观、追寻热爱的事业、不必把人生过得太紧绷。
尽管皮查伊的演讲并未因人工智能被打断,但这项技术是斯坦福学生抗议的核心议题。“Project Nimbus”中,人工智能服务和软件占据重要地位。批评者称该计划包含人工智能驱动的数据采集技术,可用于人脸识别和物体追踪。上周日的示威是该活动团体第三次在毕业典礼期间组织离场抗议——2024年和2025年曾开展规模相近的行动——诉求均为声援巴勒斯坦、反对美国与以色列的相关合作。
尽管皮查伊在演讲中刻意回避探讨人工智能的前景与风险,但走下讲台后,这位谷歌首席执行官却明确阐述了年轻毕业生将面对的全新技术时代。上月在《纽约时报》的《Hard Fork》播客节目中,当被问及如何应对斯坦福大学毕业典礼上可能出现的嘘声时,皮查伊表示,他相信年轻一代能够驾驭这场技术变革,同时也承认毕业生普遍存在焦虑情绪。
“我始终认为,每一次技术进步都会推动世界向前发展。从某种意义上说,这些毕业生既是推动技术进步的重要力量,也将承受技术变革带来的种种影响,”他表示,“我认为我们必须对此保持高度警惕。”(财富中文网)
译者:中慧言-王芳
近期受邀在大学毕业典礼上发表演讲的科技行业领袖,或许已经意识到向年轻人大肆宣扬人工智能并不受欢迎,因此调整了演讲内容。但事实证明,今年毕业季,重磅演讲嘉宾与毕业生之间的矛盾,远不止人工智能一项。
谷歌和Alphabet首席执行官桑达尔·皮查伊是今年最新一位遭冷遇的科技高管。上周日,当拥有斯坦福大学硕士学位的皮查伊登台演讲时,该校2026届毕业生集体离场。
此次离场行动由Students for Justice in Palestine斯坦福分会发起,该组织是由全美各地学生自主运营、主张巴勒斯坦解放的活动团体。该分会在Instagram发表声明,指控谷歌涉嫌与以色列政府、人工智能和数据分析公司Palantir等企业开展合作;Palantir已签订多项合约,为以色列军方、特朗普政府移民执法项目提供技术支持。
长期以来,活动人士一直批评谷歌的“Project Nimbus”——这是以色列2021年与谷歌、亚马逊签署的价值12亿美元的合同,据此,以色列军方可使用先进的云计算和人工智能软件。近年来多个亲巴勒斯坦团体接连发起抗议,谷歌管理层甚至遭到公司内部员工抗议。
记者向谷歌寻求置评,谷歌发言人援引了皮查伊演讲中的相关表述。斯坦福大学并未立即回应《财富》杂志的置评请求。
该活动团体在声明中称,数百名学生参与了抗议活动,而SFGate上周日报道称,约有200名毕业生离场。
“今天,数百名学生以实际行动向桑达尔·皮查伊表明,高薪福利或人工智能飞速发展的说辞,再也无法蛊惑他们。”该组织在声明中写道。
反AI情绪席卷全美高校
过去一个月,全美各地的毕业典礼演讲嘉宾都遭遇全场嘘声,学生普遍对“人工智能即将彻底重塑职场”的论调存疑。
上月,中佛罗里达大学毕业典礼上,房地产高管格洛丽亚·考尔菲尔德(Gloria Caulfield)称人工智能是“下一场工业革命”,话音刚落便引发全场嘘声。数日后,在亚利桑那大学的演讲现场,皮查伊的前任之一、谷歌前CEO埃里克·施密特(Eric Schmidt)按照预先准备好的发言稿阐述人工智能融入年轻人生活是必然趋势时,台下嘘声一片,他不得不暂停发言。
皮查伊早已预判到针对人工智能的抗议,整场演讲完全避开相关字眼。
“我知道今天本该给各位分享建议。但最近不少人叮嘱我该讲什么、不该讲什么,所有人给我的忠告都指向同一个需要避开的话题。”他说道。
皮查伊虽未提及人工智能,但表示这项技术“与本次演讲无关”。他在演讲中鼓励毕业生保持乐观、追寻热爱的事业、不必把人生过得太紧绷。
尽管皮查伊的演讲并未因人工智能被打断,但这项技术是斯坦福学生抗议的核心议题。“Project Nimbus”中,人工智能服务和软件占据重要地位。批评者称该计划包含人工智能驱动的数据采集技术,可用于人脸识别和物体追踪。上周日的示威是该活动团体第三次在毕业典礼期间组织离场抗议——2024年和2025年曾开展规模相近的行动——诉求均为声援巴勒斯坦、反对美国与以色列的相关合作。
尽管皮查伊在演讲中刻意回避探讨人工智能的前景与风险,但走下讲台后,这位谷歌首席执行官却明确阐述了年轻毕业生将面对的全新技术时代。上月在《纽约时报》的《Hard Fork》播客节目中,当被问及如何应对斯坦福大学毕业典礼上可能出现的嘘声时,皮查伊表示,他相信年轻一代能够驾驭这场技术变革,同时也承认毕业生普遍存在焦虑情绪。
“我始终认为,每一次技术进步都会推动世界向前发展。从某种意义上说,这些毕业生既是推动技术进步的重要力量,也将承受技术变革带来的种种影响,”他表示,“我认为我们必须对此保持高度警惕。”(财富中文网)
译者:中慧言-王芳
Technology leaders who have taken the podium as graduation speakers of late may have figured out AI evangelizing isn’t polling well with young professionals, and tweaked their messaging accordingly. But it turns out, AI isn’t the only point of tension between high-powered speakers and graduates this commencement season.
Google and Alphabet CEO Sundar Pichai is the latest tech executive to get the cold shoulder from graduates this year. Members of Stanford’s 2026 graduating class walked out of their ceremony on Sunday as Pichai, who holds a master’s degree from the university, took the stage.
The walkouts were organized by the Stanford chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine, a nationwide network of student-led activist groups advocating for Palestine’s liberation. In a statement published on Instagram, the chapter accused Google of allegedly collaborating with the Israeli government and companies like Palantir, the AI and analytics firm that has inked contracts supporting the Israeli military and the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement plan.
Activists have long criticized Google for Project Nimbus, a $1.2 billion contract Israel signed with Google and Amazon in 2021, which grants the Israeli military access to sophisticated cloud computing and AI software. Google’s leadership has even been the target of protests from the company’s own employees, as multiple pro-Palestinian groups have organized in recent years.
When asked for comment, a Google spokesperson referred to Pichai’s comments during his speech. Stanford University did not immediately reply to Fortune’s request for comment.
The activist group’s statement said hundreds of students had been involved in the protest, and SFGate reported Sunday around 200 graduates had walked out.
“Today, Sundar Pichai was met with the sight of hundreds of students who showed they could not be allured anymore with the talk of a dollar or rapidly expanding AI,” the group wrote in its statement.
The AI backlash goes to college
Commencement speakers across the country have been met with widespread jeers over the past month, mostly in skeptical response to statements about a pending workplace evolution related to AI.
When real estate executive Gloria Caulfield referred to AI as the “next Industrial Revolution” during a University of Central Florida commencement speech last month, the audience replied with loud boos. A few days later at the University of Arizona podium, Eric Schmidt—one of Pichai’s predecessors as Google CEO—had to pause a prepared statement on the inevitability of AI in young people’s lives to make space for the audience’s hisses.
Pichai was prepared in his speech for that line of attack, entirely avoiding any direct mention of AI.
“I know today is about giving you all advice. But people have also been giving me a lot of advice on what to say. Actually, it’s been the same advice, and it’s about what not to say,” he noted.
Without mentioning the technology by name, Pichai said AI was “truly immaterial” to his speech, in which he pushed graduates to maintain optimism, find exciting pursuits, and to not take life too seriously.
While AI didn’t directly disrupt Pichai’s speech, the technology does feature heavily in the subject of the Stanford students’ protests. AI services and software figure prominently in Project Nimbus, which critics say includes AI-powered data harvesting used for facial recognition and object tracking. Sunday’s demonstration was the third time activist groups have organized walkouts during commencements—following similar-size acts in 2024 and 2025—each arranged to show support for Palestine and oppose U.S. ties to Israel.
While Pichai may have shied away from commenting directly on AI’s promises and perils, away from the podium, the Google chief has been explicit about what young graduates could expect in the new technological age. When asked on the New York Times’ Hard Fork podcast last month about how he would navigate boos during his Stanford commencement speech, Pichai said he would entrust younger generations to handle the technological shift, while acknowledging graduates’ anxieties.
“Anytime we have driven technology progress I think it helps drive progress in the world, and in some ways these graduates are actually both going to be a big part of driving that progress and also dealing with the impact of that technology,” he said. “I think we have to be very mindful of that.”