Which of the following best explains the social dislocations experience by much of Europe in the 19 century?

journal article

Arbitrary Rule: A Comparative Theory of State, Politics and Society in Iran

British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies

Vol. 24, No. 1 (May, 1997)

, pp. 49-73 (25 pages)

Published By: Taylor & Francis, Ltd.

https://www.jstor.org/stable/195668

Read and download

Log in through your school or library

Purchase article

$51.00 - Download now and later

Purchase a PDF

Purchase this article for $51.00 USD.

How does it work?

  1. Select the purchase option.
  2. Check out using a credit card or bank account with PayPal.
  3. Read your article online and download the PDF from your email or your account.

Abstract

Modern studies of Iranian history and society have often been based on theories developed for the study of European society. This has led to important anomalies which can be resolved by recognizing the fundamental differences in the development of the two types of society within the framework of a single social science. Agricultural property was owned by the state, parts of which it assigned or farmed out to individuals or groups as a privilege, but not a right. There was social stratification, but the social classes did not enjoy any rights independently from the state; hence there was no aristocracy, and the composition of the social classes changed rapidly through time. Therefore there was no law outside the will of the state, which stood above the society, despite a body of rules which were subject to rapid and unpredictable change. The state's legitimacy was not founded in law and the consent of the influential social classes, and the mere success of a rebellion was sufficient ground for its legitimacy. This explains the frequent crises of succession in Iranian history. Until modern times, revolts and revolutions were led against an 'unjust' arbitrary ruler to replace it with a 'just' one. The result was generalized chaos until a new arbitrary rule was established. Notwithstanding their many differences, the two revolutions in the twentieth century were massive revolts by the society against the state for lawful government. But, despite some temporary successes, the long experience of the society proved to be more powerful than the newly acquired political ideas and programmes.

Journal Information

The British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies is a refereed academic journal published for the British Society for Middle Eastern Studies (popularly known as BRISMES). The editors aim to maintain a balance in the Journal's coverage between the modern social sciences and the more traditional disciplines associated with Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies. They welcome scholarly contributions on all aspects of the Middle East from the end of classical antiquity and the rise of Islam. Articles on the language, literature, history, politics, economics, anthropology, sociology, geography, and the religions and cultures of the region are encouraged. The British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies also includes a vigorous review section covering publications on all subjects connected with the Middle East. This incorporates a wide range of reference and bibliographical material seldom reviewed elsewhere.

Publisher Information

Building on two centuries' experience, Taylor & Francis has grown rapidlyover the last two decades to become a leading international academic publisher.The Group publishes over 800 journals and over 1,800 new books each year, coveringa wide variety of subject areas and incorporating the journal imprints of Routledge,Carfax, Spon Press, Psychology Press, Martin Dunitz, and Taylor & Francis.Taylor & Francis is fully committed to the publication and dissemination of scholarly information of the highest quality, and today this remains the primary goal.

Rights & Usage

This item is part of a JSTOR Collection.
For terms and use, please refer to our Terms and Conditions
British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies © 1997 Taylor & Francis, Ltd.
Request Permissions

Which of the following best explains the social dislocations experience by much of Europe in the 19 century?

  • Entertainment & Pop Culture
  • Geography & Travel
  • Health & Medicine
  • Lifestyles & Social Issues
  • Literature
  • Philosophy & Religion
  • Politics, Law & Government
  • Science
  • Sports & Recreation
  • Technology
  • Visual Arts
  • World History
  • On This Day in History
  • Quizzes
  • Podcasts
  • Dictionary
  • Biographies
  • Summaries
  • Top Questions
  • Week In Review
  • Infographics
  • Demystified
  • Lists
  • #WTFact
  • Companions
  • Image Galleries
  • Spotlight
  • The Forum
  • One Good Fact
  • Entertainment & Pop Culture
  • Geography & Travel
  • Health & Medicine
  • Lifestyles & Social Issues
  • Literature
  • Philosophy & Religion
  • Politics, Law & Government
  • Science
  • Sports & Recreation
  • Technology
  • Visual Arts
  • World History
  • Britannica Classics
    Check out these retro videos from Encyclopedia Britannica’s archives.
  • Demystified Videos
    In Demystified, Britannica has all the answers to your burning questions.
  • #WTFact Videos
    In #WTFact Britannica shares some of the most bizarre facts we can find.
  • This Time in History
    In these videos, find out what happened this month (or any month!) in history.
  • Britannica Explains
    In these videos, Britannica explains a variety of topics and answers frequently asked questions.
  • Buying Guide
    Expert buying advice. From tech to household and wellness products.
  • Student Portal
    Britannica is the ultimate student resource for key school subjects like history, government, literature, and more.
  • COVID-19 Portal
    While this global health crisis continues to evolve, it can be useful to look to past pandemics to better understand how to respond today.
  • 100 Women
    Britannica celebrates the centennial of the Nineteenth Amendment, highlighting suffragists and history-making politicians.
  • Britannica Beyond
    We’ve created a new place where questions are at the center of learning. Go ahead. Ask. We won’t mind.
  • Saving Earth
    Britannica Presents Earth’s To-Do List for the 21st Century. Learn about the major environmental problems facing our planet and what can be done about them!
  • SpaceNext50
    Britannica presents SpaceNext50, From the race to the Moon to space stewardship, we explore a wide range of subjects that feed our curiosity about space!

  • Introduction
    • Paleolithic settlement
      • Earliest developments
      • Upper Paleolithic developments
    • Mesolithic adaptations
    • The Neolithic Period
      • The adoption of farming
      • The late Neolithic Period
        • Agricultural intensification
        • Social change
      • The Indo-Europeans

    • The chronology of the Metal Ages
    • General characteristics
      • The Copper Age
      • The Bronze Age
      • The Iron Age
    • Social and economic developments
      • Control over resources
      • Changing centres of wealth
      • Prestige and status
      • The relationship between nature and culture
      • Rituals, religion, and art
    • The people of the Metal Ages

    • Greeks
    • Romans
    • Barbarian migrations and invasions
      • The Germans and Huns
      • The reconfiguration of the empire

    • The idea of the Middle Ages
      • The term and concept before the 18th century
      • Enlightenment scorn and Romantic admiration
      • The Middle Ages in modern historiography
    • Chronology
    • Late antiquity: the reconfiguration of the Roman world
      • The organization of late imperial Christianity
      • Kings and peoples
      • The great commission
      • The bishops of Rome
      • The Mediterranean world divided
    • The Frankish ascendancy
      • The Merovingian dynasty
      • Charlemagne and the Carolingian dynasty
      • Carolingian decline and its consequences
    • Growth and innovation
      • Demographic and agricultural growth
      • Technological innovations
      • Urban growth
    • Reform and renewal
    • The consequences of reform
      • The transformation of thought and learning
      • The structure of ecclesiastical and devotional life
        • Ecclesiastical organization
        • Devotional life
      • From persuasion to coercion: The emergence of a new ecclesiastical discipline
      • Christianity, Judaism, and Islam
    • From territorial principalities to territorial monarchies
      • The office and person of the king
      • Instruments of royal governance
      • The three orders
    • Crisis, recovery, and resilience: Did the Middle Ages end?

    • The Italian Renaissance
      • Urban growth
      • Wars of expansion
      • Italian humanism
        • Growth of literacy
        • Language and eloquence
        • The humanities
        • Classical scholarship
        • Arts and letters
      • Renaissance thought
    • The northern Renaissance
      • Political, economic, and social background
      • Northern humanism
      • Christian mystics
      • The growth of vernacular literature
    • Renaissance science and technology

    • Economy and society
      • The economic background
      • Demographics
      • Trade and the “Atlantic revolution”
      • Prices and inflation
      • Landlords and peasants
      • Protoindustrialization
      • Growth of banking and finance
      • Political and cultural influences on the economy
      • Aspects of early modern society
    • Politics and diplomacy
      • The state of European politics
        • Discovery of the New World
        • Nation-states and dynastic rivalries
        • Turkey and eastern Europe
      • Reformation and Counter-Reformation
      • Diplomacy in the age of the Reformation
      • The Wars of Religion
      • The Thirty Years’ War
        • The crisis in Germany
        • The crisis in the Habsburg lands
        • The triumph of the Catholics, 1619–29
        • The crisis of the war, 1629–35
        • The European war in Germany, 1635–45
        • Making peace, 1645–48
        • Problems not solved by the war
        • Problems solved by the war

    • Order from disorder
    • The human condition
      • Population
      • Climate
      • War
      • Health and sickness
      • Poverty
    • The organization of society
      • Corporate society
      • Nobles and gentlemen
      • The bourgeoisie
      • The peasantry
    • The economic environment
      • Innovation and development
      • Early capitalism
      • The old industrial order
    • Absolutism
      • Sovereigns and estates
      • Major forms of absolutism
        • France
        • The empire
        • Prussia
      • Variations on the absolutist theme
        • Sweden
        • Denmark
        • Spain
        • Portugal
        • Britain
        • Holland
        • Russia
    • The Enlightenment
      • Sources of Enlightenment thought
      • The role of science and mathematics
      • The influence of Locke
      • The proto-Enlightenment
      • History and social thought
      • The language of the Enlightenment
      • Man and society
      • The Encyclopédie
      • Rousseau and his followers
      • The Aufklärung
      • The Enlightenment throughout Europe

    • The Industrial Revolution
      • Economic effects
      • Social upheaval
    • The age of revolution
      • The French Revolution
      • The Napoleonic era
      • The conservative reaction
      • The Revolutions of 1848
    • Romanticism and Realism
      • The legacy of the French Revolution
        • Cultural nationalism
        • Simplicity and truth
        • Populism
        • Nature of the changes
        • Napoleon’s influence
      • General character of the Romantic movement
      • Romanticism in literature and the arts
        • Drama
        • Painting
        • Sculpture and architecture
        • Music
        • Self-analysis
    • Early 19th-century social and political thought
      • Postrevolutionary thinking
      • The principle of evolution
      • Science
      • Early 19th-century philosophy
        • Kant
        • Kant’s disciples
      • Religion and its alternatives
        • Scientific positivism
        • The cult of art
      • The middle 19th century
      • Realism and Realpolitik
        • Scientific materialism
        • Victorian morality
        • The advance of democracy
      • Realism in the arts and philosophy
        • Literature
        • Painting and sculpture
        • Popular art
        • Music
        • Summary
    • A maturing industrial society
      • The “second industrial revolution”
      • Modifications in social structure
      • The rise of organized labour and mass protests
      • Conditions in eastern Europe
    • The emergence of the industrial state
      • Political patterns
      • Changes in government functions
      • Reform and reaction in eastern Europe
      • Diplomatic entanglements
      • The scramble for colonies
      • Prewar diplomacy
    • Modern culture
      • Symbolism and Impressionism
      • Aestheticism
      • Naturalism
      • The new century
        • Arts and Crafts movement
        • New trends in technology and science
        • The social sciences
        • Reexamination of the universe
      • The prewar period

    • The Great War and its aftermath
      • The shock of World War I
      • The mood of Versailles
    • The interwar years
      • Hopes in Geneva
      • The lottery in Weimar
      • The impact of the slump
      • The trappings of dictatorship
      • The phony peace
    • The blast of World War II
    • Postwar Europe
      • Planning the peace
      • The United States to the rescue
      • A climate of fear
      • Affluence and its underside
      • The reflux of empire
    • Ever closer union?

More

  • More Articles On This Topic
  • Additional Reading
  • Contributors
  • Article History

What best explains the patterns of declining industrialization in China and India during the 19th century?

13. What best explains the patterns of declining industrialization in China and India during the nineteenth century? d. The search for raw materials and markets for manufactured goods drove Europeans to colonize Asia.

Which of the following best explains the circumstances in which Western Europe began efforts?

Which of the following best explains the circumstances in which Western Europe began efforts to create the transnational union that would eventually become the European Union? It was an attempt to prevent a return to the political and economic instability that had characterized the first half of the twentieth century.

Which of the following best explains Mudie's purpose in creating the organization described in the pamphlet?

Which of the following best explains Mudie's purpose in creating the organization described in the pamphlet? WRONG: Reformers organized political parties to push for economic changes. Samuelson's study of Le Creusot is best explained by which of the following characteristics of the British Parliament at the time?

Which of the following was the fundamental justification for the Jesuit establishment of missions like the one described in the excerpt?

Which of the following was the fundamental justification for the Jesuit establishment of missions like the one described in the excerpt? To promote the spread of Roman Catholicism throughout the New World.